Internal testimony challenges OpenAI and Microsoft’s fair use defense
The New York Times and several other US media companies have asked a federal court to reject OpenAI and Microsoft’s fair use defense in consolidated copyright litigation. Their 92-page summary judgment brief cites internal emails, Slack messages and sworn testimony, and seeks billions of dollars in damages. The case includes the Daily News group, Ziff Davis, the Center for Investigative Reporting and The Intercept.
The filing says Microsoft director Brent Hecht called AI training “an astonishing theft” and possibly the “largest theft of labor in human history.” OpenAI executive Nick Turley reportedly described ChatGPT products as largely substitutive, while Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella testified that chatbot use had replaced visits to original sources. Microsoft said Hecht’s comments were personal and that Nadella was discussing broader changes in information consumption, not copyright law.
The plaintiffs also accuse OpenAI of bypassing paywalls, using the New York Times Annotated Corpus beyond its license, and deploying a filter after the lawsuits to limit evidence of copied material. They argue the use was commercial, substitutive and harmful to licensing markets. OpenAI and Microsoft are expected to present arguments emphasizing fair use and the transformative character of their systems.
Written by Sakhanda Wire AI from reporting by The Decoder. Facts, quotes and full context are in the original article below.